Showing posts with label Filartiga. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Filartiga. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 8, 2009

Sandhu v. Burke 2000 WL 191707

Sandhu v Burke, was decided on February 10, 2000 and is currently not reported in the federal reporters. The case can be found online at 2000 WL 191707.

In Sandhu v. Burke the plaintiffs, Sukhminder Singh Sandhu and Ranjit Singh Gill were both attempting to prevent extradition to India. Sandhu was charged with robbery and conspiracy to commit robbery of a national bank in Ahmedabad, India. Mr. Gill was charged with murder, attempted murder and murder in furtherance of a common intention in connection with the shooting deaths on July 31, 1985 of a member of the Indian Parliament, his wife, and a constituent in Delhi, India.

The case history spans over a decade and had numerous procedural issues. Throughout the case the petitioners were attempting to prevent an extradition to India claiming that upon extradition they would face torture, false imprisonment and other harms.

The court heard oral arguments stating that the principles of international law preclude extradition to India even if Article 3 of the Convention (Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment) is not self-executing . Sandhu v. Burke 2000 WL 191707-10. The plaintiffs contend that under jus cogens norms of international law, the right to bodily integrity as well as the right to be free from torture and extradjudicial execution are rights that are judicially enforceable independent of any treaty. Id. The court did not agree holding that jus cogens is only applicable when there is no controlling executive or legislative act or judicial decision. Id.

In regards to Filartiga, the court held in a footnote that the reliance on Filartiga is misplaced. Filartiga concerned tort claims brought under the Alien Tort Statute...the case currently before this Court, however, arises not in the realm of torts but in the context of extradition. In the extradition context, there is no equivalent to the ATS. Id at ft.10

Friday, December 4, 2009

Hawkins v. Comparet-Cassani

In Hawkins v. Comparet-Cassani the prisoner had a stun belt placed on him prior to sentencing proceeding and later activated. Hawkins brought a civil rights action against county, judge, sheriff, and other defendants. The court held that most of the plaintiff's causes of actions were bared for one reason or another. Plaintiff cited Filartiga, claiming that the actions of the defendant constitute torture.

Plaintiff claimed that torture is a violation of jus cogens norms. When dealing with jus cogens that courts will look at different sources of law including international law.
33 F.Supp.2d 1244, 1255. (1999 C.D. Cal.) The court held that the treaties put forward by the plaintiff were not self-executing treaties (Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the Declaration on the Protection of All Persons from Being Subjected to Torture) nor were they treaties but non-binding resolutions of the General Assembly. 33 F.Supp.2d 1244, 1257 (1999 C.D. Cal). The court was unwilling to go into detail regarding Filartiga.

Friday, November 20, 2009

Buckland v Hessen

In Backlund v. Hessen, 904 F.Supp. 964, 971 (D. Minn 1995) the court held that "Plaintiff refers to article 2 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and articles 2 and 26 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights as giving rise to a claim for discrimination and cites for support Filartiga v. Pena-Irala, 630 F.2d 876 (2d Cir.1980). Filartiga concerned a tort claim by an alien arising under 28 U.S.C. § 1350 which gives district courts original jurisdiction over a claim brought by an alien in tort alleging violation of the law of nations or a U.S. treaty. Plaintiff's claim is not in tort and does not arise under 28 U.S.C. § 1350. Filartiga cannot be read so as to recognize jurisdiction over international law-based claims not arising under 28 U.S.C. § 1350. Plaintiff provides no legal support and this Court has found none indicating that he has a claim in federal court for a violation of either the Universal Declaration or the International Covenant. Courts have declined to recognize that federal question jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1331 gives federal courts jurisdiction over a claim for a violation of international law. Xuncax v. Gramajo, 886 F.Supp. 162,"

Thursday, November 19, 2009

Linder v. Calero Portocarrero

After Filartiga v Pena-Irala was heard in the federal district court of New York a number of other cases cropped up in Federal Courts claiming the ATS as a means of getting jurisdiction over the defendant.

In Linder v. Calero Portocarrero 747 F.Supp.1452 (1990) the plaintiffs sued on behalf of the deceased, Benjamin Linder. Mr. Linder was killed by Contra rebels in Nicaragua in April of 1987. He was wounded by gun fire while at an unfinished Hydroelectric dam. He was taken and then tortured by the rebels and have between 30 to 40 wounds on his face with a sharp pointed object.

In the original complaint there were a number of defendants, including Nicaraguan Democratic Force, the United Nicaraguan Opposition, the Nicaraguan Resistance, and four individuals, Adolfo Calero Portocarrero, Enrique Bermudez Varela, Aristides Sanchez Herdocia, and Indaleco Rodriguez Alaniz. The named individuals were sued in their individual capacity for actions that took place in Florida. The organizations were largely organized and operated in Nicaragua.

The Defendants raised several arguments: 1) Court lacks subject matter jurisdiction over the action because the claims represent non-justiciable political questions, 2) dismissed under the State Doctrine, and 3) plaintiffs have failed to state a claim under customary international law and 4) the Geneva Conventions do not provide a private right of action for the defendants.

The Court held held that the political question doctrine prevented the court from hearing the case. (Id at1457) The court further held that there were no judicially discoverable critieria to resolve the serious issues raised by the claim. (Id at 1459) The court was unwilling to determine if the actors were state actors and protected by the State Action doctrine (Id. at 1457-1458.)

Linder v. Calero then goes on to distinguish the facts of this case from Filartiga v. Pena-Irala which was cited by the Plaintiff. The Court held that Linder involved a U.S. citizen and that the ATS allowed for aliens to bring an action, not U.S. Citizens. The court stated that the plaintiff must show that international law unambiguously provides a cause of action for their claim. The court noted that in Filartiga the Court found official torture to be a clear and unambiguous violation of the law of nations...however, the case at bar differs from Filartiga in respect to the status of the parties allegedly inflicting torture. The contras are private individuals whose actions simply do not represent state action. (Id at 1462) The court further held that domestic tort actions are not appropriate remedies for injuries occurring outside the United States during conflicts between belligerents. (Id at 1463)

The plaintiffs appealed the decision of the court and was heard by the United States Court of Appeals and can be found at 963 F.2d 332. The Court of Appeals held in part the defendants motion to dismiss and remanded in part. The court held that there is no foreign civil war exception to the right to sue for tortious conduct that violates the fundamental norms of the customary laws of war (Id at 336). Regarding the political question doctrine the court stated, " In our view, this presents no difficulty in going forward with the case. Under the allegations of tort liability that we have explicated, the complaint challenges neither the legitimacy of the United States foreign policy toward the contras, nor does it require the court to pronounce who was right and who was wrong in the Nicaraguan civil war. On the contrary, the complaint is narrowly focused on the lawfulness of the defendants' conduct in a single incident." (Id at 337)

Tuesday, November 10, 2009

Filartiga part 3

In 1980, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit heard Filartiga v Pena-Irala 630 F.2d 879 (C.A.N.Y. 1980) and determined that torture violated universally held norms and was a violation of the law of nations. The original lawsuit claimed the following causes of action: “wrongful death statutes; the U. N. Charter; the Universal Declaration on Human Rights; the U. N. Declaration Against Torture; the American Declaration of the Rights and Duties of Man; and other pertinent declarations, documents and practices constituting the customary international law of human rights and the law of nations,” as well as 28 U.S.C. sec. 1350, Article II, sec. 2 and the Supremacy Clause of the U. S. Constitution. Jurisdiction is claimed under the general federal question provision,28 U.S.C. sec. 1331 and, principally on this appeal, under the Alien Tort Statute, 28 U.S.C. sec. 1350 (id at. 879)

On May 14, 1979 the suit was dismissed on jurisdictional grounds. The plaintiffs were given 48 hours to apply for other forms of stay, but were denied on these grounds as well. Shortly thereafter Pena left the country. The court put heavy emphasis on The Paquete Habana 175 U.S. 677 (1900) in stating that courts must interpret international law not as it was in 1789 but as it has evolved. The court then quotes the U.N. Charter stating that a states treatment of its OWN citizens is now a concern of all nations. (Filartiga at 881) The Court quotes further U.N. language holding that the torture of one's citizens is not to be had and that all persons shall be free from torture. (id. at 882-883) The court concludes that it is the proper venue in that federal courts have always had the ability to hear cases concerning international law.

Tuesday, October 27, 2009

Background on Filartiga

This post will attempt to portray what events happened in the Filartiga case leading up to the lawsuit in federal court. Full description of the events are beyond the scope of this blog and the judicial opinion gives a decent description. Filartiga can be found at Filartiga v Pena-Irala 577 F.Supp. 860 (D.C.N.Y. 1984), however the court only gives cursory description of the events. An in depth look at the case can be found in The Anatomy of Torture: A Documentary History of Filartiga v. Pena-Irala by William J. Aceves.

The whole case underlying Filartiga occured in Paraguay. The deceased, Joelito Filartiga was the son of Dr. Filartiga, a prominent human rights advocate in Paraguay against the Stroessner regime. Dr. Filartiga had been tortured on more than one occassion in the past. Dolly Filartiga was the deceased brother and a victim of some of the actions of the Defendant, Pena-Irala. The Defendant Pena-Irala was the Inspoector General of Police of Asuncion. He happened to live a few homes down from the victims.

Joelito was tortured and killed by the defendant. According to court records in Paraguay Joelito was killed in a jealous rage when the hsband of Pena-Irala's daughter caught the two of them in bed. However, medical examinations showed evidence of torture including electricity, broken bones and stabbing. Dolly was shown the murdered body of her brother and told by the defendant that they have what they were looking for and deserved.

The legal proceedings in Paraguay were a sham. The attorney that attempted to represent the Filartiga's was threatened and he finally had to drop the case. Over time, Dolly left Paraguay for the United States to get away from Paraguay. However, she found out that Pena-Irala was in New York with his wife but had overstayed their Visa. This quickly set forth a series of events that lead to the deportation proceedings against Pena-Irala, the filing of the civil action in federal court and the begining of a case that empowered an old law.