Showing posts with label multinational corporation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label multinational corporation. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 3, 2010

Positive Aspects of the ATS

Many of the same criticisms against the ATS can be seen as positives. The debate is largely based on two groups, the big business/multinational corporations who are afraid of being sued in a US court for an action that occurred in a different country against labor groups, ethnic minorities and other minority groups. The two interest while not diametrically opposed do have a great deal of tension.

A large corporation who is afraid of getting caught doing something illegal may go to extra lengths to hide it once it is done. A large corporation may be leery of investing in a foreign country if they are worried about the political practices in that country for fear of being found an aider of those atrocities. For example Coke may not want to invest in China because of human rights abuse, which the general public or under the ATS Coke may be found liable for China's human rights abuses because of the business generated by Coke in China.

At the other end of the spectrum are the individuals or groups who are abused or have their human rights violated. For example in Pena, Joelito was tortured and killed by a police officer who was acting, either explicitly or implicitly, under the orders of the state to put pressure on Dr. Filartiga. Other examples are numerous and include ethnic groups that are forced to move or are wiped out for oil fields, workers trying to unionize in numerous developing nations being abused by the multinationals.

The debate is largely about economics from the corporations view point, they cannot operate effectively if they have to worry about being sued in a US federal court for an action that may have occurred thousands of miles away. The individuals abused see it as David vs. Goliath and they need to have their day in court and make sure Goliath does not abuse others.

Corporations claim that it will infringe on their ability to operate, critics of this argument state that by being held accountable businesses will have to operate effectively and within their own laws or face public distress or dislike. In essence a corporation is no longer able to say we will abide by human rights and then do nothing to address human rights abuses. This is a powerful idea, as most multinationals can just pick up and leave a country when the political, social or economic atmosphere is no longer to their liking. The ATS will allow an alien abused by a company grounds for redress in a US court instead of a court in their home country which may or may not be in the hands of powerful elite who have strong ties to the multinational corporation.

This debate is not going anywhere and both sides have some strong valid points. Where one falls will largely depend on what you think is more important, paying a few cents more for a consumer good, or the knowledge that the individuals who made the consumer good were well treated and not abused by the corporation who employs them.

Tuesday, January 19, 2010

Criticism of the ATS

As mentioned previously, there has been some criticism towards the Alien Tort Statute. Much of the hostility stems from corporations that do business in the United States but have a sizable presence outside the U.S. These corporations have very little difficulty agreeing to corporate responsibility, but they balk at the thought of actual enforcement of the corporate responsibility. (Roth, K 2005 'Rules on Corporate Ethics Would Help, Not Hinder Mutlinationals', Financial Times, June 21 archived at www.hrw.org) These entities argue that the ATS allows aliens to enforce codes of conduct for potential violations that occurred outside the U.S. or by a subsidy of the larger corporation.

The counter-argument is that many of the protocols or voluntary controls put forward by the transnationals do not have any form of enforcement or accountability. This means that corporations can say they are doing "good" but are not punished by violating or ignoring their own rules. (Betton, J 2008 'The Global Contact of Human Rights Violations: The Impact of the Alien Tort Claims Act' Journal of Business Systems, Governance and Ethics) These business do have a good argument in that it can be difficult if not impossible for them to police subsidies in countries that have weak and/or corrupt governments or that they should be liable for the selling of goods in a country that violates human rights (e.g. South Africa during Apartheid). The transnational corporations generally get the support of the government on their side for a number of reasons examples include - political question doctrine, there is no known complicity by the parent company, or that the ATS is granting more rights to aliens than it does to citizens.

The reality of the situation is different, the courts have traditionally found issue with the lawsuits brought by plaintiff as either lacking standing or not a violation of international norms. Furthermore, even if the plaintiff somehow wins in court there is the difficulty of collecting the judgment. The debate regarding the ATS and its impact on transnational corporations will continue to grow as the law is used more and more in federal courts.

Thursday, January 14, 2010

ATS abuse

There are some groups who view the ATS as a negative thing. The logic is that the ATS allows aliens to sue other aliens or corporations on grounds that a U.S. citizen could not claim. They further claim that it is a deterrent to multinational corporations from working in the United States if they face liability for something they may have done half-way around the globe. Furthermore, in order for a court to determine what is a tort in the violation of international norms a court must look at sources that are outside the United States and thereby diluting American jurisprudence and independence.

While each of these arguments are somewhat valid they do ignore key facts. In short, U.S. citizens generally have the same if not more rights than an alien suing in federal court; multinationals may face potential liability but given the general protections provided to corporations this argument seems weak; our courts have already been looking at international norms to determine international issues.